When is it OK to Pay-to-Play?
To some extent, we all pay to play in the art world. Whether it’s through exhibition fees, framing, or booth rentals, we often need to invest money to get our work seen.
If you’ve ever participated in an art fair, you’ve experienced this firsthand. You’re paying for the privilege of a space where you can connect with collectors, talk to customers, network, and sell your work. That’s a fair exchange—your investment gives you access and opportunity.
But things get murkier when a gallery reaches out asking you to pay upfront to show your work.
A reputable gallery doesn’t charge artists to exhibit. Instead, they curate their artists carefully—choosing work that fits the gallery’s vision, clientele, and reputation. Their income comes from commissions on sales, not from artists’ pockets.
When a gallery takes you on, they’re investing in you. They believe in your work and understand that your success is tied to theirs. Their motivation is to sell your art because that’s how both of you benefit.
Vanity galleries operate very differently. They make their money upfront—often charging hefty fees for wall space, “marketing packages,” and sometimes even taking an additional commission on top.
Because they’re paid regardless of whether your art sells, they have little incentive to promote your work. Their focus is on signing up the next artist willing to pay for the promise of exposure.
Red Flags to Watch For:
-
“Press pages” that only show the gallery’s own advertisements
-
A random mix of artists with no cohesive style or audience
-
Unsolicited invitations to exhibit or be in books—especially vague, non-personalized ones
-
Open calls or ads asking artists to “exhibit in NYC” or “gain exposure”
-
Offers for solo shows without any prior relationship or vetting
-
Testimonials focused on artists being happy—not collectors buying art
-
Resistance to consignment agreements
-
You shoulder all the risk while they collect the fees
A quick Google search with the gallery’s name plus “vanity gallery” can be very revealing.
Don’t be dazzled by attention. It’s easy to feel flattered when someone expresses interest in your work. But be wary of anyone using your art for their own gain rather than helping you sell it.
This extends beyond vanity galleries—coffee shops that want you to decorate their walls for free, or frame shops that’ll display your work only if you use their services, fall into the same category. They’re not scams, but they’re not opportunities that truly serve you either.
Don’t support anyone who wants to take advantage of you. Although these galleries are not fraudulent, they are a rip off.
But, not every situation where you pay to exhibit your work is a vanity setup. Here are a few examples of legitimate pay-to-show opportunities:
-
Artist cooperatives where members share costs and responsibilities
-
Space rentals where you host your own show and maintain full control
-
Juried exhibitions held by reputable art societies or competitions that charge a modest entry fee
These opportunities are transparent, curated, and typically offer real exposure or community value in return.
Someone once told me, “You are known by the company you keep.” That’s as true in the art world as anywhere else.
Before agreeing to exhibit, take a good look at the other artists the gallery represents. Do you respect their work? Does it align with your own? If not, trust your instincts and walk away.
The best relationships in art—like in life—are built on mutual respect and shared goals. Know who you’re doing business with, make sure the relationship benefits both parties, and focus on creating lasting, genuine partnerships.
If you want to learn more about working with Galleries, click on my earlier post—Paying Gallery Commissions.
Let me know in the comments below what has been your experience with vanity galleries.
Be well….be creative,
Click to learn more about photo encaustic classes, courses, and workshops.
AMEN AMEN AMEN. You’ve said it all very well. It’s alluring for sure, but if you do the math, all the income is on the vanity gallery’s side of the equation. I ran into such a gallery in my small home college town. Despite it wasn’t exactly like the NYC vanity galleries I’d visited when I was learning about them, it was a similar business model that benefits the gallery, not the artist. I declined their invitation. They are experiencing a revolving door of artists who eventually find out they can’t make their monthly obligations.
Thank you Annie. Yes, it’s so alluring as we want our work shown, but it’s never a good deal when it’s all about someone else. Needs to be a win-win for both. Have a lovely end to 2021 and start to the new year.
Hi Clare,
I was roped into one of these years ago and it took me until after the show to realize that that was what it was. It was an invitation to artists to send work and be “juried” into their new gallery, which looked beautiful but you had to pay for the reception and use “their” bartenders and food, a requirement to the tune of over $1,000.00 each. There were 2 of us that shared the space. What they were really doing was selling their catering business.
Some of it can be really sneaky. Frame shops can be the same…..you can have a show, if you frame all your work with us. They are really just selling their framing. Live and learn…..it’s not always easy to navigate all of it.
I feel your better off paying the fees for the open shows with other artists and showing your work in that realm with more control. Millions of people will see your work rather than a select few who visit the vanity galleries. I’ve been approached by many of these some international but really don’t want to pay the fees and allow them to handle my works.
Absolutely. Couldn’t agree more!
These have been going on for years. I attended one in Brooklyn, NY, where there were maybe 800 pieces displayed, many at least 10-12 feet off the floor, impossible to really take in visually, and the event was just a big party (wine etc. for sale) where people mingled but almost no one truly appreciating the art. NOT acceptable and not an ART event!
Totally agree. Not acceptable and not an ART event. I feel the same way about Art-A-Whirl these days. People are coming out for the bands and the drink tents. The art is just part of the entertainment.
I’ve never even heard of this type of gallery. Interesting. I belong to a co-op which I was glad to see you explained was different. I also like to apply to several well known groups to be juried into their special events….I feel this is a worthwhile way to get your work shown, and usually for me, sold.
Yes co-ops and juried shows are very different…..it’s the ones that are just selling you a magical gallery experience at an absorbent cost that you need to be careful of.